Skip to main content
TV

‘The Good Daughter’ review: A familiar thriller that mistakes trauma for depth

By November 17, 2026No Comments5 min read
The Good Daughter

The Good Daughter treads familiar ground, but key performances make it work.

Adapted from showrunner Karin Slaughter’s novel of the same name, The Good Daughter plays like an airport-purchase page-turner you read while lounging in the sun and forget about shortly after. Although family secrets, long-buried trauma, and a small town rocked by violence it never expected aren’t groundbreaking aspects of the thriller genre, the series offers enough suspense to keep viewers hooked. The drama piles on the twists, and even though it stretches credibility in the process, stars Rose Byrne and Meghann Fahy back it with an emotional earnestness its soapy plot doesn’t always earn.

Despite Peacock’s relatively minimal promotion, the series has far more in common with the twist-focused thrillers of Harlan Coben and David E. Kelley, a comparison that should entice audiences to the six-part drama, even if the streaming yet up to date on how to market a series. This time, though, Byrne sports a distracting wig instead of genre favorite Nicole Kidman.

Fresh off her Golden Globe-winning, Oscar-nominated performance in If I Had Legs I’d Kick You and her underrated turn in Apple TV’s Platonic alongside Seth Rogen, Byrne could easily lead higher-brow projects. But she anchors this pulpy thriller with a vulnerability few of her comedy roles have let her explore. Fahy similarly builds on the promise of her scene-stealing role in The White Lotus, even if the conflict-heavy scripts make you wonder what drew either actress to the project.

The Good Daughter embraces its soapiness but overdoes it with trauma.

Meghann Fahy stars as Charlotte

The plot follows sisters Charlotte (Fahy) and Samantha (Byrne) who have spent the past 20 years trying to piece together lives shattered by a night of violence in their family home at the hands of a rival family. Each episode shifts between that fateful night and the present day, when another crime rocks their hometown of Pikeville at the local school. As the case unfolds, the sisters must confront a past neither has truly escaped.

Charlotte finds herself among the first witnesses at the scene, thanks to a romantic coincidence that only a soap opera could justify, especially when it all but blows up in her face. The attack threatens to expose hidden secrets, while Samantha’s return forces the recently estranged sisters to revisit the trauma they have spent years trying to outrun. Not well enough, apparently, as both have followed their father, Rusty (Brendan Gleeson), into law, although their careers have taken wildly different paths. Samantha has built a successful life in New York, while Charlotte remains in Pikeville, largely working on juvenile cases.

As with book-to-screen adaptations, The Good Daughter handles its contrasts with the subtlety of a tonne of bricks. Samantha arrives in town at her father’s request, driven by a chauffeur, head to toe in immaculate business attire, and wears oversized sunglasses to signal that she’s above where she grew up. Her introduction is Hallmark-esque, drawing from the unattached city girl who heads home and finds herself changed, especially when compared to Charlotte’s more casual appearance and modest small-town life. Unsurprisingly, the series offers anything but the charm and escapism of a Hallmark movie, filling every episode with enough trauma to make its characters’ endless suffering feel excessive.

Before too many twists threaten to overwhelm the story.

The cast of The Good Daughter

To no one’s surprise, the sisters butt heads immediately. Byrne and Fahy make their confrontations among the show’s most compelling moments, and their chemistry undercuts their strained relationship with a believable history of two women who would do anything for each other. So long as this doesn’t involve being completely honest about what happened when they were separated that night, which plagues them, or how that has affected their relationship.

Once The Good Daughter establishes its central mystery, the series embraces its contrivances, for better or for worse. The more it reveals about the night in question, the more it risks overwhelming its characters with one traumatic revelation after another. Each new twist raises the series’ emotional stakes, but the relentless tragedy that builds undermines the impact of where the story goes. It’s also hard not to feel it’s orchestrated for Byrne and Fahy to receive award nominations, rather than because it serves the narrative.

The series also overindulges in romantic subplots. I’m a firm believer that most television would be nothing without pairings to root for, but Charlotte’s relationship troubles add little to her characterization. Instead, they feel like another excuse to create drama in a show already overflowing with it. Samantha fares little better, with memories of her husband seemingly designed to push an already traumatized woman to her breaking point.

Rose Byrne and Meghann Fahy are the draw.

Rose Byrne and Meghann Fahy

Despite its excesses, The Good Daughter boasts a cast it hardly deserves. Olivia Williams delivers a heartbreaking performance as Gamma, the Quinn family matriarch whose presence haunts much of the narrative. Williams appears entirely through flashbacks alongside Audrey Grace Marshall and Drew Cheek, who play the younger Samantha and Charlotte. Marshall and Cheek handle the sensitive material with care beyond their years, and they are the perfect counterparts to Byrne and Fahy.

Gleeson proves equally devastating as Rusty, a man whose relationship with his daughters is splintered by the weight of their unresolved trauma. His work as a criminal defense attorney has left literal and metaphorical scars on his family, complicating all attempts to reconnect with Samantha and Charlotte.

But it’s Byrne and Fahy who ultimately hold everything together. Byrne plays Samantha with a steely exterior that gradually reveals the pain and exhaustion she feels as a disabled woman beneath her cultivated success. Fahy, meanwhile, brings a rawness to Charlotte, who is ridden with resentment and guilt. She may stumble into one poor decision after another, yet Fahy ensures her impulsiveness is an extension of the trauma she has never confronted in favor of protecting her sister.

The bottom line.

At six episodes, The Good Daughter has enough momentum to stay entertaining, but a more restrained approach to genre-heavy twists likely would have made the series feel less like trauma porn and more like prestige television. Still, there’s something undeniably compelling about watching actors of this caliber together, committing to material that doesn’t always deserve the heights they take it to.

The Good Daughter is streaming now on Peacock. 


Images courtesy of Peacock and NBC.

REVIEW RATING
  • The Good Daughter - 6/10
    6/10

Leave a Reply