
James Gray’s Paper Tiger is an old school family tragedy that sees Adam Driver and Miles Teller try to reach for different kinds of success.
Opportunity is a dangerous thing. It’s great to have in your life and a cornerstone of the American Dream, but it’s also something that can be taken advantage of. Yet, isn’t that what our parents tell us to do when we grow up: See an opportunity to succeed and reach for it? Does the American Dream program us to always want more? And if that’s true, how far are we willing to go to achieve that dream? There are plenty of heartwarming stories about what people are willing to do to succeed in America. Paper Tiger, the latest from writer/director James Gray, is not one of those stories.
It’s 1986 in Queens and Irwin Pearl (Miles Teller) is doing ok. He has his own contracting business, a cozy suburban home, beautiful wife Linda (Scarlett Johansson), and two teenaged sons on the verge of becoming men. But if Irwin is doing good, his older brother Gary (Adam Driver) is doing better as a former cop now with a consulting business that comes with swagger and a Mercedes. Gary approaches Irwin with a business proposition; help a group of Russian immigrants get past some environmental regulations for work. Irwin knows he’s doing good, but with his oldest son getting ready to pick colleges, he needs to do better. Unfortunately, Irwin walks in on the Russians doing shady stuff and is now being threatened to keep his mouth shut. Gary tries to solve this problem, but he and his brother soon realize there’s no talking their way out of this.
Tale as old as time.
Gray is no stranger to New York City corruption, Russian gangsters, and familial bonds. But he doesn’t necessarily make “crime” movies in the vein of Martin Scorsese. He focuses on people trying to make changes in their lives before being pulled back into drama by their fathers or brothers. Paper Tiger is no exception with Gray doing an understated, but no less impressive job building Irwin as an average man trying to be exceptional. He’s living the American Dream with a cozy home, a successful job, and a loving family. And yet, seeing his brother flash his magnetic personality makes Irwin want to risk it all to get more. Gray doesn’t make Irwin blatantly bitter or malicious, he’s merely a victim of his own ambition. He just wants his kids to see him successful and with that, Gray makes him walk a very thin line between inspirational and pathetic.

Photo Credit: Elissa Federoff and Neon
Though Paper Tiger takes places in 1986, there’s something about that feels distinctly 70s. Maybe it’s the lack of 80s culture that’s overcompensated for in other movies, with the costume department giving everyone the same bland styles and the set designers making New York City look like it’s stuck in the Bicentennial of 1976. It could also be cinematographer (and frequent Gray collaborator) Joaquín Baca-Asay using shadows and dimmed lighting to make the movie look like a filmstrip somebody found in their grandparents’ attic. Or maybe it’s Gray’s script, focusing more on tense dialogue and the simmering emotions of his actors than flashy montages with a pop soundtrack or bits of graphic violence. It makes you think Paper Tiger was something Francis Ford Coppola would’ve made between The Godfather and The Conversation as a bridging gap between a family crime saga and a tight thriller.
Family business.
Teller is not only the best performance in Paper Tiger, but also giving the best performance of his career since Whiplash. He’s impressive playing an average joe who’s as sympathetic as he is simple, trying to be the man of the house while still being insecure of his manhood every time Driver enters the scene. Teller is great at building up Irwin’s confidence and then showing the crushing failure on his face when the truth comes out. Teller’s always been good at playing guys who are in way over their head and now that he’s pushing 40, he can parlay that into roles where fatherhood is a crucial factor to his character. Between last year’s Eternity and now Paper Tiger, Teller has found a new niche in playing well-meaning, but envious family men struggling to handle their own failures.
Teller also ricochets from some top talent in the cast. Driver is magnetic and runs almost every scene he walks into with radiant charisma. The Oscar nominee effortlessly does everything from slight hand movements while brokering deals like a Wall Street snake to solemn moments of reflection in his worsening situation. For someone seen as such an awkward personality in person, the right script and right director turns him into an untouchable movie star. It’s good to know that Driver still finds engaging parts to come alive in while facing-down another IP.

Photo Credit: Elissa Federoff and Neon
Speaking of franchise players, Johansson remains one of the best working actors in the business. There’s a believable warmness she brings to the role and she has surprisingly good chemistry with Teller. The way she can unload an avalanche of pent-up emotion without saying a word is a skill that she’s exceptional at and is on full display here. What’s even more impressive is how she pulls Linda out of that emotional spiral to make her come back to being Irwin’s support system. It’s another notch in Johansson’s belt in making her reliable for everyone from Wes Anderson to (hopefully) Mike Flanagan.
The bottom line.
Paper Tiger feels immediately timeless in the best way possible. It’s a stripped-down drama with strong writing and grounded characters facing crushing odds. Gray showcases how ambition stemming from the American Dream can easily be warped and abused into something much darker, yet we do it all for our families. Even if we fail, maybe there’s a chance our brothers or our wives or our children can succeed for us. Sometimes we have to make bold choices, even if there’s a risk of falling apart from the slightest winds.
Paper Tiger is now playing in select theaters. Watch the trailer below.
Images courtesy of Elissa Federoff and Neon.
REVIEW RATING
-
Paper Tiger - 8/10
8/10







